Climate Engagement Canada Publishes New Alignment Assessments of Focus List Companies

New alignment assessments provide the first systematic analysis of how the accounting, audit and capital expenditure decisions of Canada’s top reporting or estimated emitters on the Toronto Stock Exchange align with climate science and transition scenarios.

TORONTO | Traditional territories of the Mississaugas of the Credit, the Anishinaabeg, the Haudenosaunee and the Huron-Wendat – Climate Engagement Canada (CEC) is an investor-led engagement initiative with 60 institutional investors representing ~$10.7 trillion focused on driving Canada’s business transition to net zero. The initiative released new Alignment Assessments of Focus List companies, complementing its Benchmark Disclosure Framework Indicators by providing independent evaluations of the alignment of company actions with the goals of the Paris Agreement. These assessments, conducted by the Carbon Tracker, include Climate Accounting and Audit assessments applying to all focus list companies except certain rate-regulated utilities, and capital allocation assessments applying specifically to the Upstream Oil and Gas and Utilities sectors.

This research equips investors with direct insights on corporate decarbonization strategies and their alignment with accounting and auditing, as well as capital expenditures.  For more information on the Alignment Assessment methodology, click here.

The assessments provide a new baseline for progress – a starting point for investors to begin engagements on these topics. The findings reveal that Canadian companies are at the starting line and investors need to clarify the information needed to properly assess climate-related financial risks. These insights will be leveraged by participant investors in framing constructive engagements with Focus List companies on areas of strength, opportunity and where greater effort is needed.

ACCESS THE ASSESSMENTS HERE


Key Findings

Climate Accounting and Audit Assessments (35 companies assessed):

      • There is room for engagement with no assessed companies yet disclosing whether they comprehensively reflect material climate-related matters in their financial statements, as per Carbon Tracker methodology.
      • 8 companies partially provided key quantitative assumption and estimate information and can be encouraged to provide more complete data.
      • Across all companies assessed, audit reports require evidence that auditors considered relevant climate-related risks and the impacts of transition pathways.

Capital Allocation Alignment Assessments – Oil and Gas (5 companies assessed):

      • Only one company sanctioned new projects in the last year, and these were incompatible with Paris pathways; the others either had no new recent investments identified for analysis, or they did not greenlight new investments in the last year.
      • 3 companies did not disclose a maximum price in their commodity price forecasts used in impairment testing, or the year it was reached.

Capital Allocation Alignment Assessments – Utilities (6 companies assessed):

      • Although all companies have announced plans to control CO2 emissions by leveraging gas-fired generation as a fuel to support renewables integration during the transition, these plans exceed the International Energy Agency’s estimates for the minimum amount of gas generation required for power system stability.

CEC is committed to working closely with investor participants and Focus List companies, leveraging their insights to refine and enhance the Alignment Assessments’ impact on companies, investors and Canada’s transition to a net zero economy.

For additional information on CEC’s methodology, evaluation processes, Focus List company input, research partners and governance, click here.


CEC Disclaimer and Data Usage Terms and Conditions

The CEC Net Zero Benchmark does not score or rank corporate issuers, nor does it use overall numeric or alphabetic ratings. Please see both the CEC Disclaimer and the Data Usage Terms and Conditions for additional information.


Quotes from CEC representatives

Barb Zvan
President and CEO, UPP and CEC Steering Committee Chair
"These alignment assessments are a critical tool for investors, allowing us to bring data-driven clarity into our engagement discussions with Canada's top emitters. What's apparent is that there is a lot of room for the better integration of material, climate-related considerations into companies' financial statements. Canada's accountants and auditors have an important opportunity, and responsibility, to take a lead in filling this gap. Companies and investors need a complete picture of financial health and that picture must include material climate-related factors."
Sarah Takaki
Managing Director, Sustainable Investing, HOOP and CEC Steering Committee Vice-Chair
"Clarity on how companies translate climate strategy into capital planning helps investors identify companies with resilient business models. CEC continues to bring together investors and companies to increase climate resilience and advance climate action of Canadian companies. This first systematic analysis of accounting, audit and capital expenditures provides investors with new insights on how companies are managing climate-related financial risks and establishes a new baseline for future engagement.”
Maia Becker
Senior Director, Responsible Investment, RBC Global Asset Management, and CEC Technical Committee Chair
“As investors, it is our responsibility to continue fostering meaningful dialogue with issuers on how they are addressing climate risks and opportunities. The CEC’s assessments provide a valuable tool to inform these discussions, offering insights into the actions Canadian companies are taking to address the transition to a net zero economy.”
Kevin Thomas
CEO, SHARE, CEC Joint Secretariat Co-Lead and CEC Steering Committee Member
“Climate change can’t be a casual mention in your sustainability report. It’s something that should be on your balance sheet, part of your capex planning, and in your annual audit. If it’s not, your board, your investors and your creditors are not getting an accurate picture, and you’ll be hearing from CEC’s engagement teams on this.”
Barbara Davidson
Head of Capital Markets Transparency at Carbon Tracker
“In this first year of climate accounting and audit assessments for Climate Engagement Canada, we are encouraged by select companies disclosing important metrics. Our systematic analysis establishes a baseline for investors to engage on climate and transition-related issues with carbon-exposed CEC Focus List companies. While Canadian firms disclosed more quantitative information than US peers, no company fully met investor needs for meaningful climate transparency, and no auditor evidenced consideration of climate matters. These assessments are a valuable engagement tool and highlight the urgent need for stronger corporate and regulatory oversight.”

About Climate Engagement Canada (CEC)

Climate Engagement Canada (CEC) is a finance-led initiative that drives dialogue between the financial community and corporate issuers to promote a just transition to a net zero economy. Through CEC, 60 investor participants (with ~$10.7T in assets under management covered by the initiative) (a) help Canadian public companies among the top reporting or estimated emitters on the Toronto Stock Exchange, or those missed by global initiatives, successfully evolve their business models and transition toward our country’s climate commitments, and (b) enhance the level of transparency into Canadian climate risk exposure and transition strategies. In 2019, Canada’s Expert Panel on Sustainable Finance made a recommendation to establish a national engagement program to drive a broader and more consistent dialogue with Canadian issuers around climate risks and opportunities (Recommendation 10.2). CEC is a response to that call to action.  

Through multi-year CEC engagements, company boards and senior leaders of Canadian companies can learn about the concerns and expectations of the financial sector as they relate to a timely transition to Net Zero emissions by 2050. This includes i) Strong governance frameworks with oversight of climate change risks and opportunities; ii) GHG-emission reduction strategies consistent with the goals of the Paris Agreement; iii) Measurable, sector-relevant targets; iv) Global standard disclosures (e.g., the Canadian Sustainability Standards Board (CSSB)/International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB)); and, v) Paris Agreement-aligned advocacy activities. CEC is coordinated by its Joint Secretariat: The Responsible Investment Association (RIA) and the Shareholder Association for Research and Education (SHARE). The initiative is also supported by the international investor networks the UN Principles for Responsible Investment (UNPRI) and Ceres. 

Media Contact

For media enquiries, please contact: Ady Jonsohn ady@riacanada.ca.

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Latest News & Insights

Manifest Climate and Quinn+Partners to conduct inaugural assessment of top Canadian emitters against Climate Engagement Canada’s Net Zero Benchmark

Climate Engagement Canada Launches Benchmark to Drive the Net Zero Transition Among Top Canadian Corporate Emitters

CEC Participants Discuss Engagement Best Practices at Investment Stewardship Event

CEC at COP27: The Role of Engagement in Driving Climate Action towards Net Zero

Letter from the Chair: A Year in Review

Webinar: Climate Engagement Canada (CEC) & the Investor’s Role in Decarbonizing Canada’s Economy

Have A Question?

Please provide a short message below and a member of our staff will get back to you!